I wrote my coaching questionnaire before I had a single client.

Not a draft of it. The finished thing, the one people filled out before our first session. I sat down with a blank page and wrote out what I thought I was allowed to ask.

Here’s the part I’d still defend, and it turns out to be the same part that caused the problem. I wasn’t being careless. I was preparing. Thirty years of nursing teaches you to walk into a room already knowing something, so I built a form that would let me arrive ready. What I was actually doing was putting her plan together before she got there.

That’s a care plan. In a hospital, a care plan is the right instinct, and a safe one, because somebody upstream of me already owned the diagnosis and the orders. My plan could only be care.

Nobody was upstream of my form.

So the form isn’t a record of what I did with clients. It’s a record of what I believed my role was, before a single person tested it.

Yours probably is too.

Most of what we teach each other about scope is about the live conversation. Somebody says something, your stomach drops, you find your way through it. That’s real. It’s also the hardest place to learn anything, because it’s moving.

Your form doesn’t move. It says the same thing to every person who fills it out, it says it in writing, and it says it before you’ve met. If you want to know what you think your role is, don’t replay a hard conversation. Go read your form.

Here’s what mine said.

My form had seven sections, and five of them were good coaching:

What are your top three goals for the next three months?
Picture your life ninety days from now and tell me what it looks like.
What have you tried that didn’t work, and why? What’s worked well?
How do you learn best?
What does success look like to you?

Those are clean. The client sets the agenda and I follow it, and I’d put every one of them on a form today.

Then there’s a section called Hormone Health and Symptoms. It sits among the coaching questions in the same warm voice, but I had written it to help me decide what belonged in her plan.​

Underneath that question, nine checkboxes. Fatigue. Hot flashes. Mood swings. Sleep issues. Brain Fog. Cravings. Joint pain. Low Libido. Bloating.

I didn’t ask her what she was dealing with. I decided in advance which nine things mattered, printed the list, and handed it to her.

Those nine boxes weren’t there for decoration. I expected the answers to help me decide what belonged in her plan. But my form didn’t say when an answer should go to her healthcare provider, and no provider was reviewing it with me.

I had decided which symptoms to ask about before she spoke. Then I was going to use her selections to shape what we did next. That’s the part I needed to see.

Four boxes. Calm. Up and down. Wired and tired. Fatigued.

"Wired and tired" isn’t a description of energy. It’s a pattern, and it carries a whole physiological story with it. I put it on a form as a checkbox.

So she ticks it, because it fits. And now she has a thing. She never described it to me and I never told her she had it. I printed it, she selected it, and it happened in writing before we ever spoke.

No single verb on that line would have alerted me to what I was doing.​

Then a row of boxes, starting with HRT.

Two things happen in that question. The smaller one is that it settles what we’re working on before she’s told me anything. The bigger one is that it collects her prescription status, and my form had no plan at all for that information.

That’s the thing I keep coming back to. Not one line anywhere on the page said what happens if something she checked needed a provider. The form collected plenty. It routed nothing.

This one has a legitimate version and an illegitimate one, and the difference isn’t in the question at all. It’s entirely in what happens next.

If I’m holding that list so I know what’s already in the picture, so I know when to pause and route, that’s intake, and it belongs on the form.

If I’m holding it so I can time a supplement away from a dose, or suggest what might sit better alongside something, then I’m managing a medication list. That wasn’t the job I had agreed to do in this coaching relationship.

Same question. Two completely different acts. The form can’t tell you which one you built, because the answer lives in your head.

And here’s where mine really showed itself. That question, and the one asking about medical conditions, are the last two on the form. They sit in a section I called Life Context, after she’s rated her satisfaction with her life, checked her disruptive symptoms, and picked her energy pattern.

The safety questions came last. I had placed the questions I needed for safety at the end, as though they were background, because I’d already decided what the form was for by the time I got down there.

None of this is about asking less. A coaching intake should be thorough, and you should know who you’re working with. What changes is whether the question commits you to something you’re not the one to do.

Every one of those keeps the knowledge. Not one of them keeps the commitment. I also needed a plan for what I would do when an answer called for a conversation with her healthcare provider.

That’s the whole trick, and it’s worth saying plainly. The fix is almost never to know less or ask less. It’s to say the true thing without the part that quietly hands you a job you can’t take.​

A curriculum teaches. A protocol directs.

I wasn’t confused about that. I could have recited it. What I didn’t see is that I’d already answered it on paper, years earlier, in a document I thought was just a warm way to get to know somebody.

I wrote that form from many years of muscle memory, in a building where the orders existed, the chart existed, and there was a provider down the hall. Every question on it made sense in that building.

That form is why I rebuilt my intake from the ground up. Not because anybody caught me. Because I finally read my own writing.

The line didn’t move when I left. All the scaffolding that kept me on the right side of it did, and none of it announced that it was going.

Your form is you talking. Go read what it says.
​
​Your intake form is writing, and writing’s the hardest place to catch this, because nobody can ask you what you meant. The check I use on my own writing is free. It’s one page and takes about thirty seconds.  Get the free Three-Question Scope Check here.